I do not get this impulse to shriek in people’s faces and bring everyone down over an obviously benevolent and sweet picture that a person drew to thumb their nose at the “it’s not natural to be gay/trans/whatever, you don’t see gay/trans/whatever animals!” crowd.
In fact, I’m sick of net activists in general right now.
When did the default response to nuance become rage?
Does it have to be? Can we as a group of people sharing a common goal of total equality across the goddam board seriously afford the luxury of collapsing over minutia? These constant pissing contests are driving me insane, because I care when people scream at each other way more than when someone’s picture has a possible problematic interpretation.
Fuck this brand of fake-ass, metastatic ‘dialogue’. You can keep it.
My dash is so full of fury right now, people yelling about how this person I don’t even know is terrible and how dare I support their trans-oppressive otherizing bluh bluh. I don’t even know the artist. I don’t really care! I just liked this cool pretty thing that got reblogged and it made me smile because the world is so full of awesome shit and look at all these awesome different ways to be a parent. One tiny head was lopped off the hydra, but that’s not enough! It has possible negative interpretations!
TIME FOR A PUBLIC SHAMING!
It could have been an interesting conversation but instead I just want to log off for like a week til it all clears out and we move on to the next item of hamster wheel outrage that ultimately achieves nothing but the diffusing of our pent-up energies. How lucky we are to be able to jerk off to the sounds of our own voices like this. With our dinners hot on the table and our internet connections more or less steady.
Seriously, where’s the social justice if all it means is a public spectacle of philosophical self-mutilation as we attack each other, raise the stakes astronomically high for anyone daring to make a statement, and exclude timid, meek or just plain decent people from our in-group because they aren’t aggressive enough to defend themselves because what if they fuck up and say something dumb, or just plain ask a question with the wrong tone of voice?
I firmly believe that I shouldn’t have to be afraid to talk openly about human rights and analyze our culture WITH OTHER ACTIVISTS.
It’s not a black/white issue of “everyone stop fighting forever or die” but we sure as fuck cannot afford to chase our tail while assholes with actual power over our actual lives continue their actual literal planned campaign of discrimination against every single fucking one of us. This is not about a false dichotomy of “get along forever” versus “lose the war”. This is about my culture, the culture I helped build in my small way, puking on the sidewalk and calling it a cleansing spring rain.
I will not watch damaging, self-serving idealists ride around cloaked in terms of activism while meek people quietly bow out and take their energy and creativity with them because they don’t want to become a public example of what happens if you’re not 100% pure. I will not sit idly by while assholes take my flag of hardcore awesome rainbow revolution and use it to justify bullying. Having lofty ideals doesn’t mean you’re immune to the lure of douchebaggery! Crack a history text sometime. If you can’t even treat a guy on the internet with courtesy, how are you going to break that cycle?
People are learning that this is how activism works. That this is what “anger” means, and how “anger” should be used. They are being told that this is what people are talking about when they say I’m mad as hell and I’m not going to take it anymore.
This is a small taste of how the powers that be maintain a status quo, by making revolution appear violent, unpleasant and unwinnable to all potential rebels. You’d think we would have learned that by now. You’d think we’d stop helping the bastards grind us down.
I am leaving the social justice fandom forever. Fuck this, fuck the constant risk of making honest mistakes and being piled on.
Fuck the notion that one racefail/transfail/whateverfail makes you permanently fair game for outraged claw-sharpening from all sides.
Fuck self-destructive call-outs.
Fuck turning every moment of potential education and enlightenment into your own personal chopping block.
Fuck letting the judge and jury be more important than the spirit of the law.
Fuck interacting with people who would in all likelihood hate me if they actually knew me.
Fuck dealing with people who might at any moment turn on me because I’m not a very good tranny/sperglord/cripple by their standards.
Fuck activism as a form of social bonding complete with ostracism for people who don’t fit in.
Fuck the police, they’re still scum. At least some things are exactly as they appear in this goofy-ass world.
There. I’ve said fuck a total of fourteen times, so now I’m going to take my toys and go home. Maybe I’ll go back to being a hermit who screams at people from the woods like I was before I got involved in net activism.
Forward my fucking mail.
(Sometimes it takes a while to realize just how toxic online social justice culture can be — particularly on tumblr — but man, the endless cycle of rage-without-nuance is impossible to maintain without fucking your own head up something fierce. Or at least that’s how it was for me.)